California attorney general Kamala Harris’s agents wasted no time after this column in late January called for a criminal investigation of the former state Public Utilities Commission President Michael Peevey.
Less than five days later, investigators executed a search warrant at Mr. Peevey’s primary home in La Canada- Flintridge.
Scope of the investigation might not be broad enough.
Egregious as his alleged acts have been, Mr. Peevey could not have acted alone in securing sweetheart deals for California’s largest regulated utilities, Pacific Gas & Electric Co., Southern California Edison Co. and the San Diego Gas & Electric Co.
Utility executives discussed arrangements with him, and one of the state’s leading consumer advocacy groups often played along with whatever he did. Plus, fellow commissioners never voted him down.
What Is a Kabuki Dance?
It all stems from the longstanding PUC kabuki dance, an elaborate routine conducted by the commission, the utilities and the consumer advocate group TURN – The Utility Reform Network.
In this exercise, whenever each utility files for possible rate increases, it seeks far more than is justified. The commission cuts the request down, taking credit for holding the line, and TURN boasts of saving the public hundreds of millions.
Demonstrating the phony quality of all this, TURN’s former chief lawyer, Michael Florio, a PUC member since 2011, is under investigation for allegedly helping PG&E, his onetime “adversary,” find a sympathetic administrative law judge to hear a rate case.
In reality, everyone knows the general outlines of the outcome before any rate-case exercise begins. This is performance art, not the prudent regulation called for by California law. It now sees Californians paying the third highest power rates in the lower 48 states (http://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.cfm?t=epmt_5_6_a).
Extraordinary examples of apparent corruption became clear during the 12-year Peevey era, predictable the moment ex-Gov. Gray Davis named the former Edison president and husband of Democratic state Sen. Carol Liu commission president. This classic case of putting the fox in charge of the henhouse was reinforced when Mr. Peevey got a second six-year term from Mr. Davis’s successor, Gov. Schwarzenegger.
Links Are So Intimate
Just how connected Mr. Peevey has been was clear at an early February gala honoring him in San Francisco shortly after investigators searched his home. Sponsors of the $250-a-plate dinner included his successor Michael Picker, Energy Commission chairman Robert Weisenmiller, former Democratic gubernatorial candidate Kathleen Brown (sister of the governor and a board member of SDG&E’s parent company), former Assembly Speaker Fabian Nunez and several ex-members of Congress.
Most egregious of Mr. Peevey’s actions may have been his manipulations to let PG&E off easy after its negligence (the term used by federal investigators) led to the 2010 San Bruno gas pipeline explosion that cost eight lives.
For one thing, Mr. Peevey and fellow commissioners who fell meekly in line behind him still have not tracked the billions of dollars paid by utility customers since the 1950s for gas pipeline maintenance that was done only on a spotty basis.
It has emerged that Mr. Peevey personally signed off on an exemption allowing his old pals at Edison to replace steam generators in their San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station without a formal review of the $680 million cost, which consumers began paying long before the generators were installed and then failed, causing the plant to be retired. Other emails earlier showed Edison executives knew the generators were flawed before the installation.
Mr. Peevey couldn’t do much of this alone. Almost all of it required cooperation or at least acceptance by other commissioners, the utilities and TURN, the consumer advocate group that helped “negotiate” last year’s settlement that will see customers pay more than $3.3 billion out of about $5 billion in San Onofre closure costs. Of course, the fault for that failure lies with Edison and its supplier; no one has yet explained why consumers should pay anything.
Because so many parties have been involved in so many shady dealings, along with the kabuki dance common to all rate cases handled by the PUC, it is clear the long-term theft of billions of consumer dollars involves far more persons and companies than just Mr. Peevey. AG Harris’s office won’t say whether its investigation might broaden to include a potential conspiracy.
But legislative hearings to be chaired in mid-March by Democratic Assemblyman Anthony Rendon of Lakewood just might explore this, Mr. Rendon said.
All aspects of this investigation should consider whether a wide conspiracy went far beyond one man’s possible criminal actions.
Mr. Elias may be contacted at tdelias@aol.com. His book, “The Burzynski Breakthrough, The Most Promising Cancer Treatment and the Government’s Campaign to Squelch It,” is now available in a soft cover fourth edition. For more Elias columns, visit www.californiafocus.net