Revisiting Chinatown (Part 2)

Frédérik SisaNews

Note: I recently had a chance to re-watch “Chinatown,” a film with much to admire — particularly in its technical elements and performances. However, while the majority of critics and movies fans see it as a one of the best films ever made, I’m in the minority who disagrees. Here’s why.

Consider the last line, the infamous “Forget it, Jake. It’s Chinatown.” It’s supposed to bring to mind Gittes’ repetition of history, which also involved a tragic death in L.A.’s Chinatown. But since we only learn about his unhappy past through the odd line of dialogue here and there, it has no real resonance. The line represents a lazy shorthand of the telling but not showing variety, in which nothing is expressed other than a simple “evil happens, and you can’t do anything about it.”

Revisiting Chinatown (Part 1)

Frédérik SisaNews

[Note: I recently had a chance to rewatch "Chinatown," a film with much to admire – particularly in its technical elements and performances. However, while the majority of critics and movies fans see it as a one of the best films ever made, I’m in the minority who disagrees. Here’s why.]

Chinatown, Roman Polanski’s 1974 technically-excellent film, starring Jack Nicholson and Faye Dunaway, has been variously overpraised as a textbook perfect film, the technicolor Second Coming of film noir that simultaneously subverts expectations of the genre, and a classic contemporary instance of Greek Tragedy. But in trying to be what Wikipedia describes as a “multi-layered story that is part mystery and part psychological drama,” (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinatown) Chinatown ends up a curiously overblown affair overburdened by the unfilled promise of genuine drama.

A Guide for the Perplexed (Gentile)

Ari L. NoonanNews

Rosa Ehrenreich Brooks is a far left weekly op-ed columnist for the Los Angeles Times who has made a brief but noticed career out of routinely charging victim status. In researching the career of the radical Ms. Brooks since she received her law degree 10 years ago, I could not find a record of one thing she likes about America. As of this month, she is the newest member of the law faculty at Georgetown, one of America’s extreme left-wing universities. In the recent past, Ms. Brooks has been a paid consultant to three far left organizations, George Soros’s Open Society Institute and two selectively critical Jew-hating groups, Human Rights Watch and  Amnesty International. All three are cousins by incestuous marriage to the equally America-loathing American Civil Liberties Union. For an American, I would think the opening portion of the mission statement of the Open Society Institute would be a jaw-dropper: “An open society is a society based on the recognition that nobody has a monopoly on truth.” There is, therefore, no universal right or wrong. Your truth is yours and mine is mine. Armed with just that speck of information, what follows should not surprise you. I cannot say whether Ms. Brooks was sincere when she donned the raiment of a naive Gentile for this morning’s essay in the Times, but I can say that she told untruths and gross distortions. Ms. Brooks is vexed and perplexed by Jewish defenders of Israel for criticizing a fellow Jew who condemned Israel’s conduct during the recent Middle East War. Turning her palms skyward, the puzzled Ms. Brooks pleaded forlornly. How can you turn on Ken Roth, she asked, when he is one of you? The executive director of Human Rights Watch, who periodically reports to the public, told lies about Israel’s conduct of the war, equating its tactics with Hezbollah’s. Ms. Brooks was angry and baffled that Jews, in response, criticized Mr. Roth, one of my favorite Jewishly useless Jews.

Friends of the Library tribute to Peter Pan

Ari L. NoonanNews

peterpan.jpg

Presenting your City Council as you never before have seen them — at Saturday night’s Friends of the Library tribute to Peter Pan at Vets Park . From left, Mayor Gary Silbiger, Vice Mayor Alan Corlin , Carol Gross, Steve Rose and Scott Malsin as they appeared in the  Costume Parade. They are expected to take on a more conservative appearance tonight at 7 in Council Chambers at the Redevelopment Agency meeting. On Saturday, Council members joined more than 500 persons at the Friends of the Library’s giant Evening Under the Stars tribute that wrapped up this summer’s Culver City Reads program. 

 

Of Mr. Bubar and Ms. Davisxx

Ari L. NoonanNews

Ah, the sweet irony of Stew Bubar’s latest qualitative contribution to the public discourse. The irony was sizzling when Mr. Bubar, one of the most provocative members of the School Board in Culver City, sat down to craft a well-constructed essay for last week’s edition of the Culver City Star. Speaking authoritatively as a longtime teacher in the Los Angeles Unified School District, Mr. Bubar presented cast-iron arguments why the thuggish Mayor Wrong of Los Angeles should not be allowed to seize control of the LAUSD in his panting march toward ultimate power in the United States. I trust that Mr. Bubar, as a loyal Teachers Union member, has seen the same information that I have — that Mayor Wrong is a better bet to succeed in his coarse course toward becoming czar of LAUSD than October is to directly follow September this year. Natural opponents of Mayor Wrong’s naked grab are collapsing the way athletes do when the fix is in. Last Thursday, the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce, sensing the train was going to leave with the Chamber underneath it, hollered “me, too,” and desperately lurched for the greasy coat-tails of Mayor Wrong. But I digress.

Artists on Display for a Month

Frédérik SisaNews

The Whole Foods Market in Woodlands Hills recently put into action a community-oriented program whereby regional artists are given an opportunity to display their work. Launched with a reception, artworks are put on display for customers to enjoy and, perhaps, to purchase. On Saturday, June 10, I happily had the opportunity to share in the reception for Melisa Sharpe, whose fine art photographs will be on display for the coming month.

The location was a small, enclosed outdoor patio where sunlight poured in from large windows. A mural painted in a breezy, Italian style provided an element of ornamentation that enhanced the space without dominating it. It was a wonderful venue for a reception that featured a dozen easels, each holding a beautiful black and white photograph, and a table with fine cheeses, fruits and nuts for guests to enjoy. All told, dozens of people showed up — friends, family, co-workers, Whole Foods shoppers and staff — to enjoy images of places such as Hollywood, Santa Monica, New York and Puerto Rico.

Culver City, Recreational Vehicle Capital

Ari L. NoonanNews


     In a noteworthy stroke of irony, this heavily decorated, scraggly recreational vehicle/bus was espied in the Braddock Drive area touting the officially still-undeclared write-in candidacy of Mayor Albert Vera and the candidacy of Vice Mayor Gary Silbiger.. The irony is that traveling RV seems to be intended as a tribute to Mr. Vera for staving off an unpopular parking ordinance just before it was to be imposed  on RV owners. Mr. Vera this week won a thirty-day reprieve for RV owners.

In addition to a legend at the top declaring “Culver City, Recreational Vehicle Capital,” a line below it reads, “Look for Me on a Street Near You.”