Start with a solid romantic comedy premise. Throw in a twist by setting the story in the kitchen of a posh restaurant. Mix in a chemically reactive cast that pair lovely performances with equally lovely looks. Spice with heartfelt drama. Garnish with a cloying sauce. Serve on crisp bone-white china. Voila! A flavorful little soufflé that delivers sweet without the guilt.
I cant speak for the film of which No Reservations is a remake the German film Mostly Martha but this Hollywood fare serves the genre of romantic comedies well by delivering exactly what is expected. That it doesnt succeed in getting beyond the genre is what keeps it from being compared to a more substantial dessert. Carol Fuchs script, though very genial and witty, offers a syrupy contrast of comedy and drama that cant quite commit to either flagrant melodrama or restrained realism. Result: a dish with a slightly unbalanced mix of flavors.